Risk & Conflict | Disputes
Strata Disputes and the CRT in BC
A twenty-unit building has enough owners that no single disagreement stops the whole corporation. A four-unit building does not have that cushion. The Civil Resolution Tribunal is where most BC strata conflict ends up, it is cheap to reach, and there are specific things it cannot fix no matter how bad the relationship gets.
Key Takeaways
- 01The CRT accepts strata claims of any amount. The $5,000 limit people quote applies to small claims, not strata.
- 02Filing a strata claim costs $125 online, plus $100 if it goes to a tribunal decision.
- 03Most disputes are decided on written submissions, and parties usually are not represented by lawyers.
- 04The CRT cannot wind up a strata, order the sale of a lot, or appoint an administrator.
- 05"Significantly unfair" is the ground that most helps a minority owner in a small building.
How a CRT Strata Dispute Moves
The CRT is deliberately staged so that most disputes end before a decision is ever written. Each stage is a genuine off-ramp.
Solution Explorer
FreeA free self-help tool that walks through the problem and often produces a letter template. Many disputes end here because one side did not realise where they stood.
Application
$125 onlineYou file the claim and the other party is notified. Strata claims are not tiered by dollar value the way small claims are.
Negotiation
IncludedA secure page where the parties try to settle directly. No adjudicator involved yet.
Facilitation
IncludedA CRT case manager works with both sides toward an agreement. An agreement reached here can be made into an enforceable order.
Tribunal decision
$100If nothing settles, a tribunal member decides on the written record. Most strata disputes are decided without anyone appearing in person.
Fees as published by the CRT at the date of last review. Confirm current amounts before filing.
What the CRT Can and Cannot Decide
Within Jurisdiction
- ✓Bylaw and rule enforcement, including whether a fine was validly imposed
- ✓Unpaid strata fees, fines, and other money owed between owner and strata
- ✓Repair and maintenance of common property, and who pays for it
- ✓Actions that are significantly unfair to an owner
- ✓Access to strata records and documents
- ✓Irregularities in how a meeting or vote was conducted
- ✓Nuisance disputes between owners, such as noise and smoke
Outside Jurisdiction
- ✕Order the sale of a strata lot
- ✕Wind up the strata corporation
- ✕Appoint an administrator to run the strata
- ✕Change each owner's unit entitlement or percentage share
- ✕Decide claims where the limitation period has already expired
- ✕Hear a matter already filed in another court or tribunal
The items on the right go to the BC Supreme Court instead, which costs considerably more and takes longer. That gap is the practical reason small stratas should settle governance questions in the bylaws rather than hoping a tribunal will sort it out later.
Four Ways a Four-Owner Building Jams
These are structural, not personality problems. They follow from the arithmetic of a building with four wallets and a 3/4 voting threshold.
The blocked special levy
The roof needs replacing, the reserve is short, and a special levy needs a 3/4 vote. One owner who cannot afford their share votes no, and two owners are enough to stop it. The roof keeps leaking while the vote keeps failing.
The owner who stops paying
In a four-unit building one owner's fees are roughly a quarter of the revenue. The strata can register a lien and go to the CRT, but the budget is short in the meantime and the other three cover the gap.
The council that is also the dispute
With four owners, the people deciding a bylaw complaint are the neighbours it concerns. There is no disinterested council to escalate to, which is why small-strata disputes reach the CRT faster than tower disputes.
The renovation that touches common property
An owner wants to alter something that turns out to be common property rather than part of their strata lot. Approval needs the council, and in a fourplex that means asking the people who will live next to the construction.
The first two both trace back to reserve funding. See strata fees for why the early-year budget usually understates what the building needs, and bylaws for the voting thresholds behind the rest.
Best For
- ✓ Owners who need a bylaw enforced or a fine reviewed without hiring a lawyer
- ✓ Small stratas chasing unpaid fees, where the amount is real but not worth court
- ✓ A minority owner arguing that a decision was significantly unfair to them
Usually Fails When
- ✕ The real goal is to end the co-ownership, which the CRT cannot order
- ✕ The limitation period has run out, which the tribunal cannot revive
- ✕ The dispute is really about a relationship that no order will repair
What To Verify Before Spending Money
- → Whether your issue is inside CRT jurisdiction before you pay to file
- → That the strata followed the bylaw enforcement steps, if you are contesting a fine
- → Whether the limitation period on your claim is still open
- → What the filed bylaws actually say, rather than what everyone remembers agreeing
Common Questions
Is there a dollar limit on CRT strata claims? +
No. The CRT began accepting strata property claims of any amount in July 2016. The $5,000 ceiling that people often quote applies to small claims disputes, not strata ones. Strata filing fees are also flat rather than tiered by claim value.
What does it cost to take a strata dispute to the CRT? +
As of this review, $125 to file a strata claim online, $150 if you file by email or mail, and a further $100 if the dispute goes all the way to a tribunal decision. Negotiation and facilitation are included in the application fee. Individuals with low income can apply for a fee waiver, but strata corporations and companies cannot.
Do I need a lawyer at the CRT? +
Usually not, and in most strata disputes parties are not represented by a lawyer unless the tribunal gives permission. The process was built to be used directly by owners and strata councils, and decisions are generally made on written submissions rather than at a hearing.
Why do small stratas deadlock more than large ones? +
Because the 3/4 threshold is easier to block. In a four-unit building two owners can stop any bylaw change or special levy, and there is no larger body of neutral owners to break the tie. In a twenty-unit building it takes six owners to achieve the same thing.
What is a 'significantly unfair' action? +
It is a specific ground of complaint at the CRT, used when a strata's decision is technically permitted but lands unfairly on one owner. It is one of the more useful routes for a minority owner in a small building, because it does not depend on winning a vote.
Can the CRT force the building to be sold if we cannot get along? +
No. Winding up a strata corporation and ordering the sale of a strata lot are both outside the CRT's jurisdiction. Those applications go to the BC Supreme Court, which is a slower and considerably more expensive path.
General information about the CRT process, not legal advice. Jurisdiction, limitation periods, and fees change. Check the CRT's own site before relying on any figure here, and speak to a strata lawyer about a real dispute.
See Also
Official Sources Referenced
See How Many Units Your Lot Allows
Unit count decides whether you land under or over the 5-lot line that drives depreciation reports and reserve planning. Enter any BC address to check.